Madame Crommelynck as a turning point in Jason’s adolescence
My first impression of Jason Taylor was that he was very self conscious, and edited himself so much to others, to a point that no one really knew him (this is also similar to Holden and Esther). Jason really isn’t the “type” that all the other popular kids in his class are; he writes poetry, has nerdy interests, and has a stammer that he uses his extensive vocabulary to hide. Jason’s worst fear is that any of this humiliating information about him is revealed to his class, so he does all he can to hide it and fit in. Jason is so obsessed with the social politics of his grade and is desperate to move up from his current mid-ranked “position” in his class. He recognizes classmates, like Ross Wilcox, who didn’t used to be cool, and is bewildered by how they were able to move up. Jason begins taking any chance he can get to improve his social standing with the other kids, as well as keeping up the act of hiding his stammer and unpopular interests. One example of this is in “Bridle Path”, when Jason stumbles upon a brewing fight between Grant Burch and Ross Wilcox, and figures he can gain popularity by supporting the winner, who he thinks will be Grant Burch, however Grant ends up losing, and Jason has to fumble his way out of the situation.
His perfect chance to finally be accepted comes in the chapter “Spooks”, when Jason finds himself with Pluto Noake, Gilbert Swinyard, and Pete Redmarley, pulling a ding dong ditch prank on his teacher, Mr. Blake. Jason proves himself by courageously tying a string to the door and successfully pulling off the prank. This earns him an invitation to join “the spooks”, the group of popular kids that he’d been dying to be a part of. Jason breezes past the challenge to get into the spooks, and finally gets a glimpse of his dream life, until he begins to have doubts when he’s essentially forced to choose between the spooks, or his best friend Dean. When Jason ultimately chooses Dean over the spooks, his life at school all falls apart, and he’s sent back to square one along with the “lepers” and weird kids, as well as relentless bullying. Even though this is a new low point in Jason’s life, it leads up to a major turning point in the novel: Madame Crommelynck.
Jason meets Crommelynck in the chapter “Solarium”, when he’s invited to the house of who he thinks is the vicar, who he’s been sending his poetry to. It turned out that it wasn’t the vicar living there though, but Eva van Outryve de Crommelynck, a belgian aristocrat, who had been reading Jason’s poems, and sending them off to the vicar’s magazine. Madame Crommelynck is intrigued by Jason’s poems, and has many criticisms, but seems to genuinely want to help him. One of Crommelynck’s many criticisms is Jason’s pseudonym of Eliot Bolivar and how his anonymity diminished the value of his work. She questions many cases of Jason’s self-censorship and helps him break down why he’s so desperate for attention and being inauthentic to himself. I found it especially funny during the scene when Jason tries to stumble around telling her how writing poetry is “gay”, while she has no idea what he’s talking about. Crommelynck’s main role isn’t really to tell Jason anything he doesn’t know, but to force him to break down what he is (and isn't) writing in his poetry, and realize why he’s trying to hide his true self.
Jason’s repeated meetings with Madame Crommelynck come at such an important point in the book as well, because he’s already at rock bottom with nothing much to lose. By about this point in the book, Jason’s stammer comes out to the whole school, and although his life is worse than ever before, he doesn’t have to worry about keeping the secret anymore. In the chapters “Goose Fair” and “Disco”, Jason finally gets back his chance to be cool, not by being a phony, or by following someone like Pluto Noake around, but by breaking rules he had set for himself in his head based on the social setting of his class. Some examples are Jason returning Ross Wilcox’s lost wallet, or Jason grassing on Neale Brose’s bullying. Both of these are things that Jason would have never done at the start of the book, out of fear of humiliation; but both of them are also examples of Jason finally being true to himself. Jason’s somewhat sudden confidence at the end of the book is a result of Madame Crommelynck’s push for Jason to be authentic to who he is, and to express in real life the emotions he shows in his poetry.
- Sahnan
Great analysis Sahnan! I loved how you showed Madame Crommelynck as a mirror for Jason’s inner conflict, especially the part about her calling out his pseudonym and pushing him to be real. It’s interesting how she doesn’t “fix” him, but helps him fix himself by making him confront the truth he’s been avoiding.
ReplyDeleteHi Sahnan,
ReplyDeleteI agree that Jason's sessions with Eva were a crucial element in his CoA. For one, she taught him the motif of truthful art, which I believe stayed with Jason and ultimately influenced him to go back for Dean. Also, her critical analysis of the social dynamics (i.e., the "living hell" that Jason goes through), later coupled with his encounter with the Gypsy camp, help Jason make the decisive step towards breaking free of the bullies' influences.
Hi Sahnan,
ReplyDeleteTo me Madame Crommelynck doesn't even feel like a real person. She feels like a product of Jason's imagination that helps guide him and make him realize that his constant paranoia about how people see him is unneeded. She shows him the value of his poetry and attempts to set him on the path of a poet. While she doesn't succeed within the timeframe of the book, I feel like the lessons instilled in Jason will set him on the path of a succesful poet in the future.
This is very interesting to think about, and I do agree with you. Madame Crommelynck does really seem to serve a purpose as an outside mentor, that shows Jason that what the people he seeks to impress aren't the only option. It almost is a turning point in Jason, and this is truly where he begins to change. Great post!
ReplyDeleteWow, lots of great examples of Jason's inner negotiations with his "true self" here. I'm struck specifically by the "Spooks" chapter, in part because it hinges on the questions of 1) whether Jason IS "Spooks material"; and 2) whether it's even a good thing to BE "Spooks material." As you note, Jason makes a power move at the start of the chapter, using Hugo's method to impress the local thugs, and it represents power because he IS terrified ("cacking myself," as he puts it so memorably) but he tamps it down and does the scary thing anyway. This does seem like real potential progress for Jason--but when we look closer, there's evidence that he is NOT "Spooks material." For starters, he actually thinks about why "cherry-knocking" is WRONG--he considers the terrorized victim who will be made paranoid by the prank. A "Spook" should not worry about such things! Pluto Noak, the epitome of "Don't give a toss" energy in this book, sure wouldn't worry about Mr. Blake's feelings. But Jason does, and for the rest of the chapter we can tell on some level that the Spooks are not actually a good fit for him. At one point he berates himself for "caring too much," as he wastes precious time actually listening to "Squelch's" family talk seriously about the challenges he faces and will face when he gets older. Most of us readers LIKE the fact that Jason pauses to think about Squelch and his reality--but this is the same "sensitivity" that leads him to violate their prime directive and go back for Dean.
ReplyDeleteSo it turns out Jason is not, deep down, "really" Spooks material. And neither is Dean. Neither of them should have anything to do with this group.
Sahnan, I like your take on Evan, how she isn't just a mentor but person who holds up a mirror to Jason so that he can truly see/confront the person that is hiding inside him. I agree with how this chapter was hugely influential regarding his future decision making at the end of the novel. His ability to let go of his social status was one of the most difficult things that he did and it wouldn't have happened without Eva killing Elliot Bolivar.
ReplyDeleteI really liked how you highlighted Jason's experiences in his effort to join the spooks. I feel like working and trying so hard to get something but failing to achieve it in the end due to unforeseen circumstances is an important experience that a lot of people have. If we see choosing Dean as the correct choice (despite his being bullied for making the decision), Jason might have been spared a lot of trouble, pressures, and stress that being a Spooks member would've given him. This is definitely one of the big moments that enable the coming of age for Jason.
ReplyDeleteEva is a really interesting character to analyze. I think Jason's meetings with her played a major role in getting his confidence out and overpowering his alter-egos like Maggot or Hangman. I really like how you point out that Jason realizes he doesn't have to fit in with people like the Spooks to be "cool," as he's able to do so just by standing up for himself in Goose Fair.
ReplyDelete